I have been watching the evolution of the maritime industry for nearly 50 years. I have seen good times, and I have seen bad times. I have battled spring floods caused by ice and rain, and I have successfully navigated low water during summer droughts. I confidently raise my hand when asked if I remember using paper charts to navigate, and I have seen the wheelhouse light up with a collection of electronics that ancient mariners could never have imagined.
At the same time, I have witnessed a gradual transformation in the experience level and demeanor of Coast Guard inspectors over the years. What was once a professional relationship steeped in respect and grounded in the knowledge and capabilities of both parties has, in many cases, turned into a combative and mistrustful standoff.
In the 1990s, Adm. James Card was a key advocate of the Coast Guard’s Prevention Through People (PTP) program, which fostered an environment of trust and empowerment within the marine safety program while remaining highly focused on reducing marine casualties. The PTP offered a modern approach to safety for a modern maritime era, and it worked well. Card’s leadership set the tone and practice that nurtured a culture of honor and respect. In those days, the Coast Guard inspector and the passenger vessel operator identified problems and mutually agreed on reasonable solutions.
Today, it seems that many Coast Guard inspectors are inexperienced and arrive for inspections with an adversarial attitude. While there are still many experienced inspectors in the ranks, I am concerned about the future and urge the Coast Guard to strengthen its training program. I also encourage the Coast Guard to invite members of the industry to participate, sharing their knowledge and viewpoints with new inspectors to promote goodwill and broaden their training experience.
At the same time, mariners must also take responsibility by approaching each inspection with a positive attitude and a thorough knowledge of applicable regulations. As the maritime industry and the Coast Guard continue to evolve, it is important not to lose sight of the principles that have guided us for many years, honoring the mariner and working together with trust and respect.
